Skye Windfarm Action Group

2008: Latest News...


Before and After Pictures

Getting a photograph to accurately show what the eye actually sees is particularly difficult as the camera records everything in the frame of the picture and the eye sees what we are specifically looking at. The way we view a scene means that what we are specifically looking at, or any particularly noticeable component of the scene are the details that register in the mind. Many people will had the experience of taking a photograph of a bird or some other object which looked close when viewed with the eye but when the picture is printed the object comes out as a disappointingly small dot in the middle of the picture. This phenomenon is exploited by developers in their presentations where they very often use a standard 50mm lens and make up a scene from three photographs to give a panoramic view. This is a very unrealistic view of what the eye sees. To see these types of scene in reality would require the viewer to turn their head through almost 90 degrees to fully appreciate the scene whereas the photograph can be seen in one take. The wind farm will look incredibly small in such a photograph even though there has been no manipulation of the scale and in every respect the representation is technically accurate what one sees is an optical illusion.

The picture was taken from the far side of Loch Greshornish looking towards the campsite using some zoom on the lens to try to simulate more accurately what the eye actually sees. While a zoom lens makes the turbines look a little closer than they do when observed by the eye the relative height of turbines and hills is not altered.
The position of the turbines is the best estimate of position using the grid locations on the developer's presentation. Size of turbines is scaled using the wind monitoring mast as a guide which although not visible in this shot it was in other shots and was used to transfer the scale to these pictures.
Considering the lack of highly accurate technology to produce the image the representation is the best that can be achieved with that available. It has to be remembered however that as with any photograph this is not exactly as the eye actually sees.


2008: Latest News...


Before: Edine over Loch GreshornishBefore: Edine over Loch Greshornish

After: Edinbane SimulationAfter: Edinbane Simulation

Skye Windfarm Action Group 2005